Anna`s Pizzeria in Sun Prairie

Great pizza, fair prices and friendly staff. That says it all.

Been eating here my entire life, had pizza all over the country. This is by far the best pizza I've eaten in my life. Anna is an amazing lady!

They really need to advertise that they take CASH ONLY. I made my order over the phone. The person was friendly and courteous, but never said anything about being cash only. My husband went to get the pizza and didn’t have the cash. So now he’s driving to ATMs to get it. He went back and they got the pizza wrong! Not a great experience for our first time and the pizza was only OK. ☹️

Old skool greasy Italian pizza done right!

***HIDDEN GEM ALERT***I wish they would open another location closer to the west side of Madison!I would seriously only get pizza from them if it weren't so far away from me.Their pizza is phenomenal - only the best quality ingredients, and the service is fantastic.

Love this place. I keep taking different people back so they can share my experience.

Maybe not a ton of atmosphere but clean and AWESOME pizza!!!!

This place is solid. I saw a review touching on the interior and this isn't a traditional "sit-down" restaurant. This place is a gem though. When I have family in town we always order an Anna's pie. Family run business known for high quality ingredients and consistency. It would be challenging to find a better option.

They didn't have enough sauce on there and their toppings were skimpy. And their sauce was blah.

Excellent.

Fantastic pizza. Friendly staff. Highly recomended!

Very good pizza.

Shining star for local pizza places. Better for takeout or delivery than dine in as far as atmosphere.

Their sauce doesn't taste like any other sauce I've ever had. It is D-flippin-licious 🤤! YUM!

It's always a treat when ordering from Anna's Pizza. I have ordered here many times and have always had great pizza and great customer service. The lady at the front who takes your order always has a positive attitude and a smile every time I visit. I would definitely recommend this place if your looking for excellent pizza!

ordered a pizza a few weeks back and it was awesome. Ordered tonight and asked 4 double cheese, not double Grease. Oh and don't let me forget that you shouldn't have to ask for sauce.

We ordered take out recently and loved it! It’s a little hole in the wall family owned joint that only takes cash which usually is a good sign the food will be good. The toppings on the pizza are just the right amount and the crust is probably my favorite. It’s not too thin and not too thick, the perfect hand tossed. It’s a little greasy but that’s what makes pizza like this great! This is going to be a new go to of ours for a delicious traditional pizza!

This place has amazing pizza. It's a small place if you choose to dine in. The staff are great!

Best pizza in SP! No contest!

What a joke. The chef salad was literally an half of head of iceberg lettuce. Overpriced take home and use your own oven style pizza. Canned mushrooms. Not really fresh ingredients. Plain, thin simple crust. I will not go back. This place is supposed to be an SP icon??? What a joke.

Tiny little place with fantastic pizza.

Nothing beats Saturday night pizza from annas! Classic go to for pizza delivery. Amazing cheese love the sauce and the toppings are delish! Keep up the good work!!

Best pizza in town!!!

I'm a senior citizen, I recently went in to buy some pizza and was told CASH ONLY! OMG, its 2020, and they dont take debit, credit, Apple Pay, PayPal, nothing! I guess the Manager/owner could read the surprise on my face, he got angry and said I could leave and go get money from an ATM machine and then come back! Manager stated "if you dont like our business practices, then go open your own place", I was totally amazed, and saddened at such complete disrespect of a first time customer. Well, I did leave. I went down the street 2 blocks to Glass Nickel Pizza, (also my first visit), pizza was fantastic, the staff was friendly and competent. "Of Course", they took a card for payment. Big difference in customer service and established social manners. Glass Nickel is my pizza provider of choice. Previous reviews of Annas Pizza indicate a big dislike for their "cash only" policy.

Best pizza in the area

Great pizza and friendly service!

Yummy yummy yummy .It is cash only so be aware of that. But super yummy pizza!

This pizza is amazing! Thank you guys!

Awesome pizza!!!! Definitely worth the 30 minute drive to get it!!!

Decided to try something new here in Sun Prairie, and heard Anna's might be good. Understatement of the year, great pizza. They have a very focused menu and that definitely lets them do it right!

Cash only. Plenty of warning. Great pizza and staff

Best Pizza in Sun Prairie!Delivery is great for curing the Pandemic Blues! Definitely comfort food in these strange days. Still the best pizza in Sun Prairie.

Best Pizza in a hundred miles

Authentic restaurant-style pizza at its best. Very flexible menu allows you to build whatever pizza you would like. Although more expensive than the chain-stores, the fresh ingredients and hand-made dough make this worth the extra dollars. Expect about 45min for delivery.

It was burnt the shrimps were small they were over cooked not happy at all

Pizza is great, the owners treat u like family

Anna's you are always amazing! Friendly, great pizza. No other place compares.

This is the only pizza place that the tomatoe paste they use does not mess with my husband's indigestion. Very flavor full. And wonderful people

Very tasty pizza!

Ordered for the first time on Easter Sunday. Pizza was awesome except I ordered a pepperoni and Tomato but received a Cheese pizza for $30.00. I'd still order again, pick up this time.

Great pizza....interior is a bit lacking but the service makes up for it.

Great Pizza by a great local Pizzaria. All homemade pizzas with fresh ingrediants. The works is our favorite and is a great pizza for football Saturday/Sunday

If you like extra cheesy pizza, you've found your Mecca. Best Pizza in Sun Prairie for the money. Sure you can go to Sal's for an expensive, fancy pie. If you want some no frills goodness, come here.

I love this place, it's one of the best pizza joints i've ever had. I always come here with my dad after we go skiing. Anna always serves you herself and with a smile. She's very friendly and has amazing pizza. What else could you ask for in a pizza joint? I love this place. (:

Best pizza in Sun Prairie hands down.

Great pizza

Excellent pizza! It is definitely a no frills atmosphere, but the pizza is great! I deducted a star for one reason: They don't accept credit cards.

This is by far the best pizza in Sun Prairie. However, I was disappointed that the half and half pizza I ordered is clearly not split down the middle with toppings. It was more 2/3 and 1/3. Hopefully next time we order it will be more evenly split.

My husband and I are new to the area and decided to try Anna's. If you're looking for a classic pizza, this isn't a bad option. It isn't the best pizza I've ever had, but the sauce was very good. We would definitely try this again.

Nice pies, a bit pricey.